In "Wahl, Sheaffer and the Race for Boston" I laid out the case that Sheaffer’s earliest Sharp Point pencils were invented by David J. LaFrance, even though the patent was issued in Walter Sheaffer’s name. Some nagging questions linger: as I mentioned the last time I wrote about the Sharp Point in April, “I never found the evidence to prove whether it was the Boston Fountain Pen Company before Wahl purchased it, or David J. LaFrance on his own, or LaFrance working a fledgling pencil program for Sheaffer.” See "When the Point Was Sure".
And then there’s Charles Keeran, the man who invented the Eversharp and who helped orchestrate Wahl’s purchase of the Boston Fountain Pen Company. He was abruptly and mysteriously ousted from Wahl shortly after the purchase was consummated in early 1917, and almost immediately after Sheaffer’s Sharp Point was introduced in mid-1917.
Was Keeran forced out for incompetence, because he failed to scoop up LaFrance’s pencil design along with the rest of the Boston Fountain Pen Company, or was he suspected of actively collaborating with LaFrance and/or Sheaffer with establishing a pencil program in 1917?
One thing is certain: between 1917 (when the Sharp Point was introduced) and 1919 (when Sheaffer set up its own pencil manufacturing works in New York), the same hands were making Sheaffer Sharp Points and Redypoints for Samuel Ward.
My last article in April concluded with very similar pencils marked GF (for General Fireproofing of Youngstown, Ohio) and how they fit into this mix. I didn’t bring them up in “Wahl, Sheaffer and the Race for Boston” because their connection wasn’t quite as direct – “a tremendous amount of smoke, but no fire yet.”
And, with the April article done and in the can, I did what I always do . . . scoped around a bit to see if there were any other examples of General Fireproofing pencils out there that I might want to scoop up.
There were two.
And both add significantly more smoke:
The silver filled one was in a bunch of parts pencils in an online auction, and I didn’t notice until the package arrived that it was from Richard Lott, accompanied by a nice note that he hopes we see each other at another pen show soon. This one was in the bunch because the cap is a bit scrunched on one side:
But, I suppose it can share custody with the cap from one of my early Sheaffer Sharp Points. The parts are interchangeable:
To be honest, I thought from the auction photos it might be an unmarked Sharp Point, since the GF imprint is so faint:
But there it is – and here it is, posed between the Redypoint and Sharp Point pencils from “Wahl, Sheaffer and the Race for Boston,” proving the connection between the two:
I was disappointed that the Redypoint was clipless, since that would have provided one more nexus for comparing the two. This one does, but you might argue it proves nothing, since it terminates in a flatter, more spoon-shape tang rather than the Sharp Point’s more graceful, pointed terminus:
But . . . that’s just one style of Sheaffer clip. Another style (the one I call the “bowler clip,” since it looks like a bowler hat at the top) has an identical tang:
Advertisements at the time suggest that the bowler clip, at least on Sharp Point pencils, came after the earlier, more pointed clips. General Fireproofing pencils, however, might never have had the same clips . . . or at least, not enough of them have surfaced to know. But at last I’ve got a General Fireproofing pencil that was indisputably made by the same hands that crafted the Redypoint and Sharp Point:
From the top, these are the Redypoint, the General Fireproofing, the Sharp Point and the later Sharp Point – and note also that those double bands at either end of the barrel were dropped by Sheaffer.
And what of that gold filled example of the GF?
It has a very distinctive pattern on it, and when I compared it to all my other Sharp Points – all my other Sheaffers, t00 – it isn’t even close to anything else I’ve found. Yet it looked so familiar . . . I was sure I’d seen it somewhere . . .
Wait a tick . . . you don’t suppose . . .
A checkerboard pattern on most of the barrel – very close. The GF has squares comprised of four lines, while the match I found has blocks of five lines. And on the front, a cartouche pinched in the middle like a peanut:
That’s the GF at the top. Note that like the checkerboard pattern, it isn’t identical, but it clearly evokes the same lines. Line up fifty, or a hundred, or what the heck .... all my other metal pencils with cartouches like this, and you’ll see: there is no question that the pattern on this GF pencil deliberately, but admittedly feebly, copied the pattern on this other pencil.
And that other pencil is . . .
A Heath-clip Eversharp, made by the George W. Heath Company for Charles Keeran’s fledgling Eversharp Pencil Company before Keeran contracted with Wahl to make them for him in October, 1915. This pattern was never made by Wahl.
And then here’s the kicker: the pattern is also found on Sheaffer Sharp Point pencils. Jerome Lobner had this one recently – unfortunately, I was so preoccupied with writing that I didn’t see it, but he let me use his picture:
Time to step back and string the clues together. Between 1917 and 1919, one manufacturer was making Sheaffer Sharp Point Pencils, Redypoint pencils for Samuel Ward & Co. and pencils for General Fireproofing. The Redypoint ties in with David J. LaFrance, the pencil’s inventor. LaFrance was working for Boston when Keeran helped arrange the sale of Boston to Wahl. Keeran admittedly neglected his duties at Wahl after the sale to attend to patent disputes “etc. etc.” in New York. The GF pencil that just turned up and Jerome's Sheaffer Sharp Point copy a pattern Charles Keeran used on his Eversharps before he became involved with Wahl, which his current employer was not using. Keeran is relieved of his duties after the introduction of Sheaffer’s Sharp Point is made public.
What we need is documentation to establish when General Fireproofing was offering pencils for sale.