And I lost. Outbid in the final few seconds.
I knew I was partly responsible. I listed these as "Triads" in The Catalogue, and with more-than-usual hubbub at the Philly show about these, it’s easy to see how a small feeding frenzy over these would happen.
But the funny ending to this story comes at the Baltimore show, when Jim Carpenito says he’s got some things to show me:
Two of these have the V-mail logo on them - one has a clip, and the other does not:
The third is a little larger and has a different logo, which is consistent with my conclusion that these were made by the Triangle Pen Company after 1940:
I recognized them instantly by the discoloration on one side of each pencil as the ones from that online auction. It was tragic, really – Jim knew of our ongoing discussions about these pencils and had seen them in my book listed under "Triad;" I bid far more for them than they were worth just because I wanted them for an upcoming article; and the articles explained why I don’t think they were worth what people were charging for them.
I felt a sense of obligation to buy them from him for what he paid, packaging in a few other pencils in the deal to soften the blow for both of us. Here’s one of the others that was included:
It’s another Triangle Pen Co. pencil, in a really nice plastic:
I do have to correct one thing I wrote in my previous articles: I referred to these as "cheap nose drive pencils" on more than one occasion. The smaller V-mail pencils shown above fit that description, but the larger two that I got from Jim are in fact rear-drive.
And the red, white and blue Farm Bureau example, with its bullet-shaped top cap, looks suspiciously like it might have been made by Ritepoint . . . hmmm. . . another day, another research project . . .