Sunday, October 14, 2018

Plaid Might Be Next

This article has been edited and included in The Leadhead's Pencil Blog Volume 5; copies are available print on demand through Amazon here, and I offer an ebook version in pdf format at the Legendary Lead Company here.

If you don't want the book but you enjoy this article, please consider supporting the Blog project here.

At the Raleigh Pen Show last June, the Saturday night auction featured a better than average selection of pencils, from the estate of the late Frank Tedesco, including these jaw-droppers:


These are early Esterbrook pencils - those with plain silver barrels were cataloged as the “PS” pencils, for “Push Sterling.”  One of these two is sterling, with a nice crisp imprint – unusual since they were stamped right where they were likely to wear off from the friction of the cap:


The other is gold filled – not cataloged and exceedingly rare.  There’s some pitting in the finish and the imprint isn’t as nice, but you won’t hear me complain:


What places these two just a bit farther to the left of “holy cow” in terms of rarity are the longitudinal lines running the lengths of the barrels and up the caps.  They nicely complement the ringed pair that I picked up from Jim Ryan’s family at the Ohio Show last November (see page 213):


All together, they make for a stunning new family portrait:



Saturday, October 13, 2018

Bridging the Gap

This article has been edited and included in The Leadhead's Pencil Blog Volume 5; copies are available print on demand through Amazon here, and I offer an ebook version in pdf format at the Legendary Lead Company here.

If you don't want the book but you enjoy this article, please consider supporting the Blog project here.

Janet and I took our semi-annual pilgrimage to the Springfield, Ohio Extravaganza, the enormous indoor/outdoor flea market/antique show that takes fully two days to see – if, like me, you feel compelled to leave no stone unturned.

Under one particularly fruitful stone, this one lounged in a sky blue plastic Tupperware container:


The seller thought it was “bent,” so it cost me just a buck or two.  It isn’t bent at all, though – that unique shape is intentional and so distinctive I knew exactly what it was:


Here it is, shown next to a Parker bridge pencil.  That’s not a generic name:



The pencil is found both with or without the lettering on its three sides – Jim Carpenito has one sans letters as well, and both his and mine show no signs of wear to indicate that letters were ever present. 

I’ve written about these before – Joe Nemecek’s example was featured in Volume 1, at page 318.  I decided to circle back around to the topic because there was something I left out in that last article:


The “Parker Bridge Pencil and Scorekeeper” was featured in the company’s in-house publication, Parkergrams, on August 26, 1935.  “The lettering is etched in silver and cannot rub off,” the brief summary states, further supporting my belief that unmarked versions are simply unmarked rather than being worn or deteriorated.

Friday, October 12, 2018

The Tangled Web

This article has been edited and included in The Leadhead's Pencil Blog Volume 5; copies are available print on demand through Amazon here, and I offer an ebook version in pdf format at the Legendary Lead Company here.

If you don't want the book but you enjoy this article, please consider supporting the Blog project here.

Today’s pencil turned up, like so many extraordinary finds, in someone’s junk box.  It was at the DC show last August – all I remember is picking it up, thinking a casual “huh” to myself and parting with just a few dollars to bring it home and think about sometime.

I’ve thought about it a lot now.


At first blush, this unassuming pencil doesn’t stand out in a crowded box full of metal pencils.  What drew that “huh” and a couple bucks out of me was the name:

“Fine Point / Pat. Apl. For.”  Initially, I thought this might be a Mabie Todd ripoff on “Fyne Poynt” or something, and so it landed into a pile of things I was going to get around to photographing after I finished editing the very book you are reading.

As fate would have it, this is the same book that both makes sense of this pencil and also sends my mind reeling a bit regarding what it means.  I’ve seen the name “Fine Point” before . . .



That’s a page from an undated catalog illustrating products of the General Manufacturing Company, makers of Snapfil pens and Kaligraf pencils; the article originally ran in The Pennant in Spring 2015, and it’s reproduced earlier in this book, starting at page 41.  I’d forgotten all about that – I know, read your own damned books, Jon.

Before I show you a few things about the pencil, there’s a couple points to bring you up to speed on: first, that article originally ran as a sidebar to an article Daniel Kirchheimer wrote in that same issue, in which he established that Sheaffer lifted, borrowed or otherwise appropriated the “Balance” shape, name and concept from General Manufacturing.  On page 42, I noted that the pencil on the left in that catalog page resembled an early Sheaffer Sharp Point, but there wasn’t enough detail to be certain.

Now that I have an example of a Fine Point in hand, I can tell you it doesn’t just resemble a Sheaffer Sharp Point – it is one:


It has the same cap, eraser retainer and mechanism.  Also, there’s some details in the barrel chasing that are telling:


Note that extra ring at the nose end, in the same position on both.  Even though the patterns on these two pencils is not identical, note the way the machining “punches” in at the nose end, rather than being a smooth line.

And there’s more.

In that article on page 42, I was able to better identify some of the other pencils in the General Manufacturing catalog as having been manufactured by Hutcheon Brothers.  When the Fine Point is positioned between the Sheaffer Sharp Point and a Hutcheon “Finerpointe”:


We have a Sheaffer Sharp Point cap and a Hutcheon clip and similar name blended into one pencil.

Thursday, October 11, 2018

The Big Oops

This article has been edited and included in The Leadhead's Pencil Blog Volume 5; copies are available print on demand through Amazon here, and I offer an ebook version in pdf format at the Legendary Lead Company here.

If you don't want the book but you enjoy this article, please consider supporting the Blog project here.

I goofed, and I might as well get this over with.

Of all the books I've written, American Writing Instrument Trademarks 1870-1953 is the one of which I am the most proud – it contains more than 2,000 trademarks, many of which were unknown to many pen and pencil historians simply because of the chaotic manner in which historical trademarks were (or were not) maintained by the Patent Office.

The book includes one trademark it shouldn’t, and it is missing another -- one very important one, which is near and dear to my heart.  Unfortunately, I don’t even get to take credit for finding the omission - it was discovered by an avid reader who picked up the book and who noticed what appeared to be an innocent typographical error.  It involved the trademark for “Redmanol”:


This is the trademark I shouldn’t have included, because it is not a writing instrument trademark strictly and it wasn’t indexed where all the other pen and pencil trademarks were found.  However, when I pulled the registration certificate from the Patent Office database, I didn’t think anything of it: Redmanol, a competitor of Bakelite, was used in the manufacture of pencils before Bakelite successfully sued the company for patent infringement and absorbed it.  I was intimately familiar with the Bakelite/Redmanol story because I wrote about it here in the course of researching the “Craftsman” which was made of the stuff (see Volume 3, page 97).

My anonymous reader, though, noted that I had the number wrong in the database listing.  Instead of registration number 124,149, I listed it as registration number 125,149.

There’s the one I left out of the book.  I typed the wrong number into the USPTO’s document retrieval portal when I pulled the certificate.  It certainly wasn’t the only time I did that over the course of months of research, but every other time I did so, the certificate which came up was so obviously wrong that I rechecked the number and pulled the right one.  This time, by coincidence, the certificate I pulled looked like it belonged – and it did, although not as much as number 125,149:


Charles Keeran, godfather of the American mechanical pencil industry, filed his first trademark for “Autopoint” in block letters, claiming a date of first use of July 15, 1918 – when the company was founded.  Oh, my forehead has such a flat spot now.  I knew about the mark: it appears on the first announcement for the new Autopoints, which appeared in the May, 1920 edition of Typewriter Topics:

I even noted this earlier trademark when I wrote about early Autopoints such as these in Volume 4, page 88 and 326, and the mark appears on the early Autopoint pictured on page 21 of The Catalogue. 




All I can say is that there’s an error in the trademark book, and I assure you it is one which pains me more than it pains you!

Wednesday, October 10, 2018

A Fascinating Suggestion

This article has been edited and included in The Leadhead's Pencil Blog Volume 5; copies are available print on demand through Amazon here, and I offer an ebook version in pdf format at the Legendary Lead Company here.

If you don't want the book but you enjoy this article, please consider supporting the Blog project here.

When this one popped up online, I questioned whether I know too much about this stuff or nothing at all:


The pencil itself is easy to identify – it’s identical to the “Modern,” made by the Hoge Manufacturing Company, makers of the ubiquitous “Pal” line of pencils (not to be confused with A.A. Waterman’s “Modern Pen Company” – for that full story, see Volume 2, page 159-161).


What’s curious is the price band: Redipoint Ingersoll, model 210E.


The band is easy to date with some precision, given the history of the Redipoint brand.  In 1922, Brown and Bigelow associated with William H. Ingersoll, recently
out of a job after the failure of the Ingersoll Watch Company.  Shortly after, The Ingersoll Redipoint Company was organized, and Redipoints were offered under this label until January, 1926, when Herbert Bigelow reacquired the brand after his release from federal prison (for more on that story, see Volume 4, page 335). 

Redipoint price bands aren’t adhered to the barrel, so I suppose a random Ingersoll Redipoint band could have been swapped over to a Hoge “Modern” if some unscrupulous seller wanted to enhance the value of an otherwise ordinary pencil – but I don’t think that’s what happened.  First, I gently moved the band down a bit and noted decades of grime built up around it - if this band was added to an unrelated pencil, it was added a good long while ago.


Then there’s a curious detail concerning the pencil itself.  While every other example of the Modern I’ve seen has this same imprint:


My Redipoint-banded example lacks any markings whatsoever:


Finally, while I have several Redipoints with price bands, none are identified as model 210E.

Something clicked in my head.  The accommodation clips found on the Hoge Modern are just like what you’ll find on early Redipoint pencils . . . and I’ve never been able to pinpoint who made those early examples (although I’ve always doubted a calendar and advertising specialty company would have done so on its own – at least, at first). 

Does this example suggest that the Hoge Manufacturing Company made those first Redipoints for Brown and Bigelow, and after the Redipoint became a hit, Ingersoll Redipoint acquired its former supplier and sold remaining Hoge stock under the Redipoint name? 

It’s thin, but I’ve seen thinner. 

Tuesday, October 9, 2018

Chapter and Verse

This article has been edited and included in The Leadhead's Pencil Blog Volume 5; copies are available print on demand through Amazon here, and I offer an ebook version in pdf format at the Legendary Lead Company here.

If you don't want the book but you enjoy this article, please consider supporting the Blog project here.

At https://leadheadpencils.blogspot.com/2018/02/settles-issue-in-my-mind.html, I was decisive in attributing a low-quality, unmarked pencil to Carter’s Ink Company, based on the distinctive Pearltex celluloid which was unique to the company.


I heard no complaints that my conclusion was too speculative, but I did admit that I would like to see  chapter and verse.” I don’t quite have it, but I have something close:


Advertisements like this one appeared in several newspapers in late 1933 and early 1934 (this is from the Asbury Park (New Jersey) Press on December 22, 1933.  The artwork is crude, but you can make out the high-placed joint on the pencil, and a shorter tip.   Yet that box appears to be just an ordinary cardboard box, not what I would hope to see – something like these:


I’ve always admired the celluloid boxes which accompanied Carter pens and pencils, and at the Raleigh pen show I finally had the opportunity to pick up two.  From what I recall, the square one came from Deb Kinney, while the one with more rounded corners was on Nikola Pang’s table.  Nikola gets a kick out of this blog - in fact, he put his penmanship skills to good work in DC, creating a slogan for my lead company I’ll never use during a late-night, slightly alcohol-influenced calligraphy session:


Yeah.  That would look great on a T-shirt, huh?  Anyway...



The more squared-off box contains a flattop set, fully marked, while the box with a more oval profile contains an unmarked set nearly identical to the blue pencil from that last article:



Note that both have the longer tip I’d normally associate with a Carter’s, providing a smooth evolutionary transition between the two:


And while the set is unmarked, the box itself has something you don’t see on those earlier, squared-off ones:


“Carter’s,” on the inside of the lid.

Wednesday, October 3, 2018

Volume 2 and Beyond

A funny thing happened on the way back to the blog . . .


It's hard to believe it has been five months since my last post.  For those I don't see at pen shows and who aren't on facebook, you might be thinking I croaked.  In fact, I've been hard at work on yet another project.

When I last wrote, The Leadhead's Pencil Blog had just been released, but I had already made the decision to format a second volume and have it ready, just in case there proved to be demand for the books.  I priced it as low as I could, so that when that first run of copies sells out, I've broken even -- I figured if/when I broke even on the first one, I'd do the second.  After the first run of Volume One sold out in less than a month, I pulled the trigger and had Volume 2 ready at the DC Show.

The first run of Volume 2 sold out in a week.

You know where this is going . . . as I write this, Volume 3 has been out for a week - and the first run is almost gone, so the entire 5-volume series is a go.  (If you've missed out, there's ordering information for copies of all three volumes at the end of this article - I've since reordered additional copies to keep in stock.)

Volume 4 -- the real monster in the series, in terms of complexity, depth and size -- will be out in a few months.  It's planned for Chicago next May, but what the heck - since Volume 3 came in a month and a half early, maybe I'll have it for Baltimore.  Just a few moments ago, I finished compiling and indexing the last of the article into Volume 5, tentatively planned for release at the 2019 Ohio Show.

The good news is that as things stand, Volume 5 is 304 pages long - exactly as long as Volume 3, but some 70 pages shorter than Volume 4.   That's good news because I'm not happy with the way Volume 5 ends: since I wasn't planning to stop when I did, I had a few killer articles in the hopper that had not made it to the blog yet.

So I've got room in the book for a few socks-knocker-offers - things I've found and learned that will give the book an ending that's more memorable than how I left it.  I've got a short list of about 20 articles that are "musts" in closing out this last Volume, but if there's questions I've left unanswered or if there's something you'd really like to see, drop me a line -

In the meantime, I'm going to organize my thoughts and get behind the camera.

(NOTE:  To order copies of the first three volumes:

Volume 1:  Leadhead's Pencil Blog Volume One
Volume 2:  Leadhead's Pencil Blog Volume Two
Volume 3:  Leadhead's Pencil Blog Volume Three