I’ve picked up a few other (non-Nozac) pencils over the last few months. I’ll start with one from the company’s “$1.00 Pencil” line of the mid-1920s:
One of these – I don’t remember which – I picked up because I couldn’t remember if I had a red one. I did, but it still didn’t wind up in my duplicates box, because of a couple subtle differences. Some of these lack that band around the nose:
In the case of Parker, a band like that indicates the crimping which holds the outer shell onto the mechanism; in the case of Conklin, apparently that band was purely decorative. And then there’s a small difference in the tops:
The only catalog in the PCA’s library which shows these pencils is the 1926 edition where it appears only in black, red and light blue . . .
. . . with a band around the nose and the longer top. So the only documentation out there is for a pencil that matches neither of these.
The next catalog I know of that shows Conklin’s dollar pencils is the 1930-31 edition, also in the PCA’s library, in which the number 6 appears in a tiny picture at the bottom of page 8:
Note that Conklin’s dollar pencils evolved backwards from what you might expect – from a straight ferrule with an exposed eraser to a crown cap more typical of pencils from the early 1920s. I’ve found a couple of these recently:
The upper example matches what’s shown in the catalog, with gold-plated trim (not very well plated, in fact) and the Mooney 1918 patent clip. The other, however, has cheaper steel trim and a very un-Conklin z-clip:
Were it not for the imprint, I wouldn’t have guessed this other one was a Conklin, and since the development of this line has already proven counterintuitive, I wouldn’t hazard a guess as to which came first – or even whether they were offered at the same time. The steel trim example isn’t working very well, due to wear on the internal parts; that’s unfortunate, but it does provide an opportunity to show you what’s inside:
Had soft aluminum not been used for the barrel liner, this would be a pretty elegant nose-drive mechanism.